The other night in class our guest lecturer expressed curiosity over what backgrounds lead people to librarianship. The professor pointed to my right and said, “Tracy has a doctorate in French.” She pointed to my left and said, “Katherine has a master’s in anthropology.”
Then she pointed at me, and she said, “Matthew, I know you have an advanced degree, but I can’t remember what it’s in.” On the spot, I had to cop to just a bachelor’s in polisci. At this confession, my professor got an “a-ha!” look and said, “Oh, that’s right. Matthew only has his bachelor’s, but he has interests.”
Now it is extremely important to note that this was said without even a hint of condescension, was said without the vaguest sneer. On the other hand, the construction is inherently cutting and, outside the singular instance in question, has probably never once been uttered without the intention to wound.
I love this teacher, respect her, adore her. But she is the library-school equivalent to John Houseman’s Paper Chase character, if that means anything to you. She is not intentionally abrasive, but she is professorial. Her deserved and earned confidence strikes some as arrogance, but in my opinion such estimations are far from the mark. This is all a roundabout way of saying that the professor under discussion would never intentionally insult, even slightly, a student in class.
Knowing this, I was not offended by the statement. I was a little startled, but I trust that this teacher always acts in good faith and, besides, there was no irony detectable in her tone. Still, it was freakin’ weird.
This did lead to an interesting, near-Seinfeldian discussion during the break, though. About midway through I made reference back to that utterance and the two women in class were all like “I know! I couldn’t believe she said that!” They agreed with my assessment that the phrasing was accidental, but they turned out to have been perhaps even more shocked than I to have heard it. The other guy from the class, though, hadn’t even realized that the phrase used could even possibly have been intended to be hurtful and in fact seemed oblivious to the fact that such a statement could possibly be used as an insult. I can’t help but think this says something interesting about gender roles, but that’s probably for later.