After giving it a couple of listens, I’m sure it will be a good-looking film.
Johnny Depp can actually sing. This is not high praise, mind you, nor actually any sort of praise at all. It simply means he has something of a voice, can hit the requisite notes, and can maintain the appropriate pitch. Johnny Depp can sing just like the top American Idol contestants can sing: technically competent, offensive in its studied inoffensiveness, and with every scrap of passion scraped out and replaced by generic tics meant to signify appropriate emotions.
Perhaps the most interesting aspect of Depp’s vocal performance is something so blatant that I pegged it on my first listen: When preparing his vocal performance, the actor seems to have considered each phrase in isolation, as a thing in itself and removed from the whole of the song and way, way removed from what might be considered a consistant and meaningful whole of a role. Because of this, his performance within each song staggers around inchoately, giving eight or nine interpretations within each piece but failing to provide anything meaningful overall.
At least his accent is well-done. Or, rather, his accents are well-done, for he switches randomly between two. At times he does a rather accomplished Cockney, sounding just like a young Michael Caine. At other times, and for no apparent reason, he switches over to the plummy, refined tone that always reminds me of Sebastian Cabot. At least he does them both well.
The same cannot be said of Helen Bonham Carter, whose attempt at Cockney is deplorable. Her accent sounds like she adamantly refused to do a typical cartoonish accent but had only actually ever heard those caricatures. What we get, then, is an arbitrarily toned down and subdued cartoon. Ugh.
But can she sing? No. Not even in the American Idol style. Hell, not even in the drunken karaoke style. The ProTunes is laid so heavily onto her tracks that at times she sounds like she’s standing inside a grain silo, her voice massaged and stretched and tweaked until it develops a tinny echo. And she still sounds like shit.
Worst of all is that the production’s heart isn’t even in the right place. The major stage productions have realized that Sondheim’s Sweeney Todd is a Grand Guignol melodrama. The show is driven by the characters’ overheated emotions and their willingness to engage in deeds most sinister with the barest provocation. The show is operatic, all grand gestures and oversized characterization. Most of all, it is suffused with a black-hearted sense of fun–the audience should give a morbid grin at the fact that the two leads end Act One by concocting a business plan that revolves around murdering random strangers and grinding them into meat pies.
The snippets of dialog present on the soundtrack suggest that Burton, god knows why, decides to play everything as straight as possible. Bonham Carter’s Mrs. Lovett is neither Angela Lansbury’s saucy wench nor Patti Lupone’s calculating slattern; she’s just a woman who finds an untapped market to revitalize her failing business. Likewise, Depp’s Todd is not the familiar cypher animated by vengeful rage but is instead some guy moping over his bad luck.
The chorus’s recurring “Ballad of Sweeney Todd” pieces, which not only give the show structure but also do a lot to create and maintain its cheerfully macabre tone, appear to have been eliminated altogether. Burton appears to have done everything he could to make the narrative as “naturalistic” as possible, much to the work’s detriment.
Of course, they’ll still be getting my ten bucks on or around Christmas Day. Because I’m a sucker, see.