(OK, this post has been lying around for nearly a year now. I’ve thought about polishing and publishing it at least once a week, so I guess it’s time to finish it up.)
A good long while back, I was lurking in a gay.com chatroom devoted to the city I was visiting. It must have been around Pride season, as that became the topic of conversation.
A very conservative and vocal chatter proclaimed that he wouldn’t be participating in any Pride activities because he didn’t believe in it. He didn’t believe in Black History Month either, and for the same reason. It was stupid and unacceptable and downright anti-American to celebrate membership in a group of people, he said.
And there was rebuttal, and he went on, and I so very much lost interest. He continued predictably through “reverse discrimination” and into “special privileges”, and then he played his trump card: “It burns me up that black people and Mexican people and even gay people have holidays celebrating their ‘pride’ and ‘heritage’, but you’d never hear of white people getting to do the same thing. Can you imagine what we’d hear from PC police if we had a day celebrating German heritage?”
Ahem. You probably don’t know this, but Missouri has a huge German heritage. And because of this, most every Missouri town of any size has an Oktoberfest celebration every year. Every Missouri town including the one the chatter lives in.
When people talk about “male privilege” and “white privilege” and such, this is what they mean. They don’t mean that every white man is born with a +5 Spoon of Silver, they’re talking about being able to chug a stein at Oktoberfest while at the very same time complaining about how white people never get to celebrate their cultural heritage.
My school has a huge annual St. Patrick’s Day celebration. It’s a week-long thing, and the campus actually shuts down for three days because, really, it wouldn’t be worth it to go through the motions of holding classes. The St. Pat’s thing is integral to the school’s identity; it’s not just a holiday that pops up unexpected, it’s a topic of conversation year-round.
It’s also an engineering school, so the student body skews conservative. Know what this means? It means that a sizable contingent spends February snarking about Black History Month even while they’re gearing up for an outsized celebration of Irish culture and heritage.
That’s not privilege in itself. What’s privilege is that they don’t see, and don’t have to see, the disconnect. It’s not so much about getting some sort of material bonus just for existing, it’s more like living in a world that was designed with people like you in mind.
Just to be clear: Enjoying the benefits of privilege doesn’t make you a bad person, or even a skeezy person. It is worth paying attention to, because it helps reduce the possibility of being an unintentional asshole.